DebateOurFuture - New GOP Bill Challenges Bush Iraq Policy

Home

New GOP Bill Challenges Bush Iraq Policy

Leading GOP Senators Draft Iraq Bill Demanding Bush Change Strategy, Narrow Mission of Troops
By ANNE FLAHERTY The Associated Press

Two top Republicans cast aside President Bush's pleas for patience on Iraq Friday and proposed legislation demanding a new strategy by mid-October to restrict the mission of U.S. troops.

The proposal, by veteran GOP Sens. John Warner of Virginia and Richard Lugar of Indiana, came as the Pentagon conceded a decreasing number of Iraqi battalions are able to operate on their own.

"American military and diplomatic strategy in Iraq must adjust to the reality that sectarian factionalism is not likely to abate anytime soon and probably cannot be controlled from the top," the Warner-Lugar proposal states.

Democrats and the White House were dismissive of the proposal. However, it could attract significant support from GOP colleagues who are frustrated by Iraq but reluctant to break ranks with their party or force the hand of a wartime president.

The two senators are considered the GOP's foremost national security experts. Warner was the longtime chairman of the Armed Services Committee until stepping down last year, while Lugar is the top Republican on the Foreign Relations Committee.

The legislation also draws heavily from existing GOP-backed proposals, increasing the chances of attracting support.

It would require Bush to submit by Oct. 16 a plan to "transition U.S. combat forces from policing the civil strife or sectarian violence in Iraq" to a narrow set of missions: protecting Iraqi borders, targeting terrorists, protecting U.S. assets and training Iraqi forces.

The bill suggests the plan be ready for implementation by next year.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid balked at the proposal because it would not require Bush to implement the strategy. He said he prefers legislation the Senate will vote on next week that would order combat troops to be out of Iraq by next spring.

Warner and Lugar "put a lot of faith in the president that he will voluntarily change course and voluntarily begin to reduce the large U.S. combat footprint in Iraq," said Reid spokesman Jim Manley in a statement.

Earlier on Friday, Reid dismissed as too soft a separate proposal supported by several Republicans and Democrats that would require Bush to adopt the recommendations of the bipartisan Iraq Study Group, intended to pave the way for a 2008 withdrawal.

"If you give this president a choice, he will stay hunkered down in Iraq for years to come," Reid, D-Nev., said.

Bush spokesman Tony Fratto said the White House would review the Warner-Lugar measure. "But we believe the new way forward strategy which became fully operational less than a month ago deserves the time to succeed," he said.

In addition to requiring a new military strategy, the legislation calls on Bush to seek renewed authorization for the war, which Congress gave him in 2002. Many members contend that the authorization which led to the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003 was limited to approval of deposing Saddam Hussein and searching for weapons of mass destruction.

Through top aides and in private meetings and phone calls, Bush has repeatedly asked Congress to hold off on demanding a change in the course of the war until September, when the top U.S. commander, Gen. David Petraeus, and U.S. Ambassador Ryan Crocker, deliver a fresh assessment of progress.

But many Republicans, most of whom will face voters next year, say they are tired of the war, which is in its fifth year and has killed more than 3,600 troops.

In a report to Congress this week, the White House conceded that not enough progress was being made in training Iraqi security forces the linchpin in Bush's exit strategy for U.S. troops.

At a news conference Friday, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Peter Pace, said the number of battle-ready Iraqi battalions able to fight independently has dropped from 10 to six in recent months despite an increase in U.S. training efforts.

Pace said the readiness of the Iraqi fighting units was not an issue to be "overly concerned" about because the problem was partly attributable to losses in the field.

"As units operate in the field, they have casualties, they consume vehicles and equipment," Pace said.

In another development Friday, Bush's top spokesman appeared resigned to the fact that the Iraqi parliament is going to take August off, even though it has just eight weeks to show progress on military, political and other benchmarks designated by the United States.

However, Tony Snow said, "Let's also see what happens because quite often when parliaments do not meet, they are also continuing meetings on the side. And there will be progress, I'm sure on a number of fronts."

The Warner-Lugar proposal is the first major legislative challenge to Bush's Iraq policy endorsed by the two senators. Lugar and Warner have previously expressed grave doubts about Bush's decision to send 30,000 extra troops to Iraq. But both remain reluctant to back binding legislation that would manage deployments.

"I have great respect for the constitutional separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches and the authorities granted to each in that document," Warner said in a statement Friday.

Associated Press Writers Pauline Jelinek, Lolita C. Baldor and Jennifer Loven contributed to this report.

(This version CORRECTS that the quote on Warner-Lugar faith in the president was from a Reid spokesman, not Reid)

Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Copyright © 2007 ABC News Internet Ventures

Comments (0)

Trackback(0)

Write comment

You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites! title=

Debate Todays News events

1/4

Laws Require Flags to Be Born in USA

The Associated Press -- ROSEMOUNT, Minn.
What's red, white and blue and made in China? A move is on in state legislatures to ensure that the flags folks will be flying and buying this Independence Day were made on this fruited plain. Minnesota has passed the strongest measure, a new law that goes into effect at year's end requiring every Old Glory sold in state stores to be domestically produced. Violations are a misdemeanor, punishable by up to a $1,000 fine and 90 days in jail.

World

Saudi religious police spur growing backlash ASSOCIATED PRESS - RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — After the car stopped outside a Riyadh amusement park, two bearded men dragged the driver from behind...

Kurds rely on Turkey for workers, goods

National

We Cannot Afford To Be Surprised In Space by CaptainJennifer WhitakerPeterson AFB CO (SPX) Jun 28, 2007"Today, we're at the high water mark when it comes to integrating space capabili...

Politics

Chertoff rebukes Congress over bill By Eric Pfeiffer - Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff yesterday scolded senators for failing to pass an immigration bill with new border an...

Family

Tech Tools Let Seniors to Stay in Their Homes Tools May Allow Monitoring of the Elderly, Which May Allow Them to Remain IndependentJune 24, 2007 — The view from Al Bailey's Portland, Ore...

Religion

Louisianans OK partial-birth ban BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — The Louisiana Legislature approved a ban on a late-term abortion procedure yesterday, the first state to do so since th...

Nigerian to end gay rights tour at D.C. church

Regional

City gambles that new type of lottery will pay off By Jim McElhatton - The D.C. Lottery"s Quick Cash game had been around for more than 15 years when Todd Zimmerman walked into Rodman"s Drug...

Mark Warner weighs another bid for office

Economy

Waiting for Wii ASSOCIATED PRESS - NEW YORK By 9 a.m., the line outside Manhattan's Nintendo World store was snaking down the block. More than 100 people hoping t...

7-Eleven brings in the 'D'oh!' ahead of film

Immigration

Inaction Begets Reaction: Stalled Immigration Reform Sparks Problems by Henry Fernandez, © Center for American Progress, July 11, 2007 Now that Congress and the Bush administration have...

Immigration bill quashed

Terrorism

Britain arrests 2 more in car bomb cases ASSOCIATED PRESS - GLASGOW, Scotland — Britain announced two additional arrests today in the failed car bombings in London and at Glasgow's ...

U.K. Police Make 5th Terror Arrest

Health

One-third of Americans abuse alcohol in their lives CHICAGO (AP) — More than 30 percent of American adults have abused alcohol or struggled with alcoholism at some point in their lives, and few h...

Siegel's Cancer Crusade Began Before His Own Diagnosis

Environment

Wood-Boring Insect Detected in Michigan Sirex Woodwasp Found in Mich.; Wood-Boring Insect Native to Europe, Parts of Asia and Africa The Associated Press LANSING, Mich. A wood-boring i...

Policy

New GOP Bill Challenges Bush Iraq Policy Leading GOP Senators Draft Iraq Bill Demanding Bush Change Strategy, Narrow Mission of TroopsBy ANNE FLAHERTY The Associated Press Two top Republica...

Defense

Allies Left Behind? Iraqis Who Helped U.S. Feel 'Betrayed,' Marked for Death Advocate Tries to Bring Pro-American Iraqis to U.S., but Says 'Politics' Get in WayKirk Johnson is the keeper of what he calls the saddest list in the...

Education

Intel to Join Board and Make Peace With `$100 Laptop' Project By BRIAN BERGSTEIN :: The Associated Press :: BOSTON As Nicholas Negroponte stormed the developing world trying to drum up buyers for the innovati...

Debate Our Featured Bloggers

First Time Visitor Information
Are you a first time visitor? Click here to learn how you can debate the important issues of the day through the use of video, blogs, articles and forums.

Post your videos to YouTube, MySpace, or Yahoo Video. Use descriptive tags and include a "DebateOurFuture" tag as well as a descriptive title and it will be posted here within 24 hours.
Debate News Events
Debater Home Pages
- maddogs pages: George Bush Pictures (254 hits)

Debate Search

Advanced Search
Debaters Online
No users online
Guests: 10
Frontpage Login
Register for a membership.It's free! Forgot Password? | Register
Premium subscribers get full access, read here for information.

Heated Forum Debates

Re:Chertoff rebukes Congress over bill
maddog 01-08-07 23:04

Stalled Immigration Reform Sparks Problems
Bill Payor 30-07-07 06:49

Chertoff rebukes Congress over bill
mj1256 30-07-07 06:37

Barack Obama: My Plans for 2008
GeekHead 30-07-07 06:33

More...

Polls & Public Opinion

Presidential Election Internet Poll. Should the next President commit to and support the following?

Build an affordable nationwide highspeed wireless Internet access system??
		yes
		no
Declare the Internet a public good and treat Internet access the same way we do water, highways, electricity etc?
		yes
		no
! Declare a net neutral standard?
		yes
		no
Build a connected democracy by broadcasting local and national proceeding for all to see?
		yes
		no
VoteResults